In Out Pizza Slices NY Style | Authentic New York-Style Pizza Fresh Stromboli in Greensboro, NC

Overview

Located at 1025 Alamance Church Rd in Greensboro, In & Out Pizza Slices NY Style delivers an authentic New York pizza experience right to North Carolina. This cozy pizza restaurant stands out not only for its classic slice offerings but also for an impressive menu that includes calzones, gourmet pizzas, and flavorful lunch specials designed with care and quality ingredients.

The highlight here is the attention to authenticity and freshness. Each slice and calzone is crafted to order, ensuring that the dough is perfectly thin and crisp, and the toppings are vibrant and flavorful. Whether it’s the tangy BBQ Chicken Pizza, the savory Buffalo Chicken, or the unique Philly Cheese Steak, the craftsmanship is evident. For non-pork eaters, their use of beef pepperoni is a considerate touch that broadens appeal.

What truly elevates the experience at In & Out Pizza Slices is the welcoming atmosphere and genuine hospitality. Owner Al’s hands-on approach and the enthusiastic service from staff like Kasey create a community feel spacious enough for casual family dinners yet intimate enough for quick solo bites. Customers repeatedly praise the friendliness and personalized attention that make the restaurant feel like a neighborhood gem.

This spot clearly aims to satisfy both pizza traditionalists seeking true NY-style slices and those looking to explore more gourmet or hearty options like large Strombolis or wings seasoned to perfection. It attracts locals and newcomers alike who appreciate both quality food and warm service in a relaxed setting.

Patrons often mention that while prices might be a notch above typical chains, they find the quality, taste, and care well worth the investment. From fresh sauces and thoughtful ingredient choices to the inviting environment, In & Out Pizza Slices NY Style proves itself as a top contender in Greensboro’s pizza scene. Whether stopping in after a long day or grabbing a slice before errands, this place invites you to savor the flavors of New York with every bite.

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Offerings

Comfort food

Quick bite

Atmosphere

Casual

Trendy

What Customers Say

Garrett Moore

Mar 29,2026

5/5

Great pizza. It's a bit more expensive than a chain pizza store but the quality is unmatched. So much better. Kicking myself for not coming here sooner. Definitely local and the customer service is great. When you get a slice you can tell it's made to order and the flavor is authentic. Food that tastes like there's some care put into it versus just being made to be efficient.

Aziz Penny

Mar 29,2026

5/5

Very good pizza very good service. The one thing I did love the most about it is I don't eat pork and they have beef pepperoni. Definitely five stars will be back very soon.

Tiffany Springer-Askew

Mar 29,2026

5/5

We were on our way for a grocery run, when we were waved down by Al (the owner) to stop and try some free samples. He was soooo welcoming and friendly. Truly GREAT customer service, which is hard to find is this area. He walked my husband to the front door and he was immediately given a great greeting from all the staff inside. And, they actually were enthusiastic to greet him, did not seem forced. Ending our day on a Friday, after a long week of work, it really was a nice way to the end of our day. We were going to get frozen pizza for dinner, but Al changed our mind to try theirs. And, we're soooooo glad we switched it up and made that choice. We ordered the pizza and fried ravioli. Both were so delicious! Fresh sauce, fresh ingredients! We definitely will come back again and you should try it too!

Shawn K.

Mar 29,2026

5/5

We had a great experience at In-&-Out Pizza! We met the owner Al who was very hospitable and our server Kasey was awesome! We ordered the BBQ chicken and Philly cheese steak and they were great! We also had an order of Lemon Pepper wings and they were very tasty as well! We'll be back and highly recommend you stop in for a bite! 10/10

scott0449

Mar 29,2026

5/5

A friend of mine and I were sitting on his porch discussing rekindling. Our friendship and a gentleman stopped and gave us two flyers for this restaurant. We immediately went to it, and it is absolutely one of the most fabulous pizza places I believe I’ve ever been in the people are friendly. The food is untouchable. They make it with love so find yourself down here and patronize this restaurant because you will be nothing but pleased. I told them that if I didn’t have anything to do on a day and I like to drive I would drive 50 miles to this restaurant just to eat and this is coming from someone that drove three hours to change the oil in a girl’s car of a really good friend of mine her sister so all of this is true. Overwhelmed by their selection I ordered the 20 inch pizza and the large Stromboli original but I’m a leftover guy and the food is so fabulous that I’ll must be tickled to death for a few days. Scott Shepherd is my name and I promise you you’ll be nothing but pleased.

Skyler Michaux

Mar 29,2026

5/5

Super clean, great service and the food was really good. The owner is super nice and inviting and so is the staff. This is my third time eating here and I plan on coming back tomorrow to try the wings and Stromboli lol. 3 slices fries and a steak and cheese sub( sub didn’t make it to the picture )

Katrina

Mar 29,2026

5/5

Greensboro you must try this place! I tried the Chicken Alfredo Pizza(thought I ordered the chicken Alfredo bowl) and a slice of pepperoni pizza. After picking up the pizza I decided to try the pepperoni slice while in the parking lot. Why did i do that, because we had lunch in the parking lot until we were full. My girls tried the chicken Alfredo pizza. The pizza is so authentically delicious. The flavor and texture of the crust, cheese, sauce is so delicious. The chicken Alfredo pizza is a must try. If you love chicken Alfredo you will love this pizza. The Alfredo sauce and mozzarella cheese compliment each other on a thin chewy crust. This is the best pizza I've had in three years. I am excited that they are in Greensboro NC. If you order here you will not be disappointed. Next, I'll try their wings.

Daquan Bryant

Mar 29,2026

5/5

I stopped in during my lunch break to treat one of my students to pizza. I’m from Brooklyn and I wanted my student to experience an authentic New York pizza. I found this place on Google and had to check it out. I felt the New York vibes as soon as I step in the door. I met Al, who was bringing all the energy.. And best of all the pizza was top-tier NY style Pizza. I will be back soon and telling others about this Hidden gem.

In & Out Pizza Slices NY Style - in Greensboro, North Carolina, USA

Overview

Amenities & Services

What Customers Say

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

More in Greensboro, North Carolina, USA