Menu of In & Out Pizza Slices NY Style in Greensboro, North Carolina, USA

Menu Overview

In & Out Pizza Slices NY Style, located at 1025 Alamance Church Rd in Greensboro, NC, is a standout gem for pizza lovers craving authentic New York-style slices and more. From the moment you step in, the inviting atmosphere and genuine hospitality – notably from owner Al – set the stage for an exceptional dining experience that goes beyond just food.

The menu is thoughtfully curated, blending classic Italian-American favorites with gourmet options. Appetizers like the Toasted Ravioli and Bacon Cheese Fries serve as perfect starters, setting a delicious tone. The Garlic Knots, available in 6 or 12 pieces, are notably fresh, with a perfect balance of garlic and buttery richness that complements any meal.

The heart of the menu lies in their diverse pizza selection. The Gourmet Pizzas, including the Buffalo Chicken, Meat Lovers, and the In & Out Special, are crafted with fresh sauce and quality toppings that speak volumes about the care put into every pie. Customers frequently highlight the authentic flavor and the made-to-order freshness that makes each slice memorable. The inclusion of beef pepperoni caters thoughtfully to those avoiding pork, showcasing the restaurant’s attention to dietary preferences without sacrificing flavor.

Not to be missed are the hearty calzones. Whether it’s the Steak Calzone or the Meat Lovers variety, these large, well-stuffed calzones offer a satisfying, flavorful experience. The create-your-own (CYO) option allows for customization, ensuring a personalized and indulgent meal.

Customer reviews emphasize more than just taste. Garrett Moore praises the unmatched quality and genuine flavor, pointing out that while prices may be a bit above typical chains, the culinary value and customer service justify every penny. Tiffany Springer-Askew’s experience reflects the warmth of the staff and the freshness of the ingredients, noting that the fresh sauce and overall care contribute to a truly elevating pizza experience.

The all-around hospitality—from Al’s welcoming demeanor to attentive staff like Kasey—and the consistent quality of dishes like BBQ chicken pizza, Philly cheesesteak pizza, and Lemon Pepper wings build a loyal local following. Scott Shepherd’s story of driving long distances to return underscores the authenticity and love ingrained in every dish. This is a place where food is crafted with passion and where the customer feels like part of the family.

In & Out Pizza Slices NY Style is not just about filling plates—it’s about offering a slice of New York's pizza tradition with fresh, thoughtfully prepared ingredients and exemplary service. Whether you’re in the mood for a quick slice, a hearty calzone, or an appetizer to share, this Greensboro hotspot promises a deeply satisfying, authentic pizza experience that stays long after the last bite.